Great Bay Insurance is an admitted homeowners insurance company owned and managed by a team of insurance professionals who have been servicing the coastal New Jersey market for over 70 years combined.

The Great Bay Story

Seventy years ago, the family of the current Great Bay founders started an independent insurance agency in Cape May, NJ with the desire to deliver quality insurance products & services to residents of the coastal areas of southern New Jersey. Continuing in the family direction to better serve the residents of coastal New Jersey, the founders of Great Bay are now offering coastal homeowners insurance from their own insurance company – Great Bay Insurance Company.

A Great Day With Great Bay
Located on Lakes Bay in West Atlantic City, and just a few miles from the ocean, Great Bay is run by third- & fourth-generation coastal NJ residents, who live in homes along the coast and who have been professionally involved in the coastal homeowners insurance business for a combined 100 years of experience. We were born here in New Jersey, raised here, went to school here, live here, raised our families here, and have worked here our whole lives – we know New Jersey, the coastal areas, and the insurance needs of coastal New Jersey residents.

Become a member of our Great Bay Coastal Homeowners Community.

At Great Bay, we evaluate the hurricane risk of each NJ home individually. Unlike typical insurance companies, we do not group you in with homes in other parts of the country which would negatively effect your policy premium. We offer an innovative set of quality options to meet your coverage needs as well as your financial budget. Contact us today to get started on your homeowners insurance policy and see first-hand what a great difference that Great Bay can make.

Great Bay Advantages

  • leadership team
  • your neighbors
  • tailor your insurance policies
  • innovative & customer-focused
  • friendly & responsive service

The Great Bay team knows coastal New Jersey and we know coastal homes.

Headquartered right here in West Atlantic City, The Great Bay Team works & lives along coastal New Jersey and fully understands the nuances of coastal homes & coastal living.


insuring coastal homes for New Jersey residents.